Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Side Veggies
Zuppa Di Pesche
Eggplant Parmesan
Sausage, Peppers, Onions
About
Bizzarro Pasta & New York Pizza
If you're searching for a hidden gem in Maggie Valley, look no further than Bizzarro Pasta & New York Pizza. Nestled at 1560 Soco Rd, this charming family-operated restaurant serves up a delightful array of Italian cuisine that leaves patrons raving and returning for more. With its inviting ambiance and friendly staff, it's a perfect spot for both local families and visitors seeking a taste of authentic Italian food.
Bizzarro's menu is a celebration of classic Italian flavors, featuring standout dishes like Chicken Piccata and Lobster Ravioli. The Eggplant Rollatini and Chicken Marsala are also must-tries for those looking to indulge in hearty entrees. If you're in the mood for something hearty yet comforting, the Clams Entree and Sausage with Peppers and Onions shine brightly, marrying fresh ingredients with rich flavors.
But it’s the pizzas that have drawn rave reviews from customers like James Barnes, who speaks highly of the meat pizza's irresistible flavors, robust toppings, and perfect crust. Pair that with their scrumptious calamari for an appetizer and you have a meal that never disappoints. Moreover, the atmosphere is cozy and welcoming, making it an ideal choice for a relaxed family outing or a casual dinner date.
Don’t forget to save room for dessert! Bizzarro's homemade Tiramisu is the perfect sweet finish to any meal, adding a touch of Italian romance to your dining experience.
Whether you're grabbing a sandwich like the Meatball Parmesan Sub or diving into a plate of pasta, every bite at Bizzarro Pasta & New York Pizza is crafted with care and passion. It’s a place where food lovers can come together to enjoy vibrant flavors and remarkable hospitality. For a flavorful journey that captures the heart of Italian cooking, Bizzarro Pasta & New York Pizza is a must-visit in Maggie Valley.
For inquiries or to place an order, feel free to call them at +1 828-944-0007. Experience the taste of Italy without leaving North Carolina, and prepare to be amazed!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Looked to be a small family operated restaurant. Food was delicious! Had Stromboli and Meatball Sandwich with Onion Rings. Service was excellent. Went in between lunch and dinner, not too crowded and plenty of parking. Highly recommend. ”
“ We love Bizzarro! In our opinion, it's the best Italian around. We usually get the Meat pizza. It's hard to not get it. But all the other food we've tried is good, too. Tonight, the wife and our friend got pasta dishes. Fresh ingredients, full of flavor. We usually get calamari for app and it didn't disappoint tonight. I got the Hawaiian with bacon and jalapenos added. Delish! Friendly staff and awesome owners. It NEVER disappoints. ”
“ One of the best BBQs in Haywood County. If you want to ribs get there early. When I arrived, McKenna let me know that they were out of ribs and only pulled chicken and/or pork. I ordered the pulled pork, and it was super. It was difficult to pick a side as they all looked great. I would not hesitate to return, but I’ll get there earlier. ”
“ Extremely cozy environment. Delicious, fresh food. Friendly, hard-working staff. Worth the wait. BBQ place near Bizzarro's seemed out of a lot of items, so an unexpected surprise! ”
“ Can't remember her name but the straight dark haired waitress that's in her early 30s maybe, very small built petite..absolutely gorgeous and she was so nice and did an amazing job. The pizza is awesome it really is, but I do wanna go back just to see her..lol. BEAUTIFUL AMAZING! ”
“ Absolutely fabulous father's day lunch. This is my dad's go to spot and the rest of us finally got to eat here too! Some of the most AUTHENTIC real Italian food I've ever had. I ordered the stuffed manicotti. I tell you what! That was incredible. It was not store bought pasta tubes. They were made in house CREPES! The way it should be. The rest of the table ordered eggplant Parmesan (dad's fave), Philly cheese steak (amazing), meatball sub (some of the best meatballs I've had at a restaurant) and our son ordered a kids pepperoni pizza (it was at least an 18" pizza). There were 3 non alcoholic drinks and 2 alcoholic. Our total bill was only 105. Oh, and we ordered calamari and an anti pasta salad. So worth the money. So delish! And this review is coming from a private chef (me) so I can be a little picky . Bravo chef. We will 100% be back as soon as we can! ”
“ You wouldn't expect a classic Italian restaurant in a small town, but here you go! Gus and his crew cooking up some of the best Italian dishes New York style. The food is authentic and incredible, with plenty of selections. The portions are generous and the service is outstanding, yet feels like you are at a family dinner table. You will be truly satisfied with the experience here. ”
“ Great little restaurant with AMAZING food and service. Cozy atmosphere. They can get busy but its well worth waiting for. Fresh ingredients. Authentic Italian and NY pizza with 2 cooks and a small kitchen. Great hidden gem! ”